First impression: Everlane silk is really nice quality, especially for the price. Weighty with a nice sheen. The fit and colors are where my hesitation lies. I ordered the Slim Silk Shirt in black and the Silk Round Collar in light grey. First the Slim Silk Shirt:
Here's a side view:
It doesn't quite skim over my hips like I'd like, but I'm not sure going up a size would fix this. I do like that it fits nicely through my narrow shoulders which almost never happens.
Now, the Silk Round Collar:
I bought the Round Collar in a medium because I liked the light grey color and they were sold out of the small. It's an older style (from before they moved to number sizing) so probably won't be restocked. It's definitely an oversized fit and the sleeves are a bit long, but they look pretty cute rolled up, so that doesn't bother me. And I adore the cute round collar. But, does it look too big?
The color is a very light warm grey and I like it, but I'm not sure it's super flattering on me. (Definitely different than anything I own.) I do love the length and how it skims over my hips:
Ugh, what do I do? I can keep both, return both, get the round collar in a small (but only in black) or get the slim in a size up? Or I can try a different style altogether and see if that works? I do like the blue colorway in the relaxed fit, but ugh. I hate having to return and return and return.