So, here are the products that are on my face even if I'm just running out real quick to pick something up at the store that may or may not be a bottle of wine:
Concealer is my everything. If I can only have one product, it's concealer. I'm on my second tube of IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye (review here) and it really is such good stuff. Its great under the eyes and also works to hide brown spots or blemishes. Definitely best if warmed up a bit and then patted on with the pointy end of a Beauty Blender, but also just fine applied with fingertips. It's waterproof and you only need a tiny bit, so a tube will last a really long time.
Benetint is one of those products I keep coming back to. I've been using it for years because nothing else I've found has the same kind of staying power. You have to work quickly but the results are very pretty and very natural.
I never used to have to fill my brows but now that they're thinning it really makes a huge difference in how I look if fill them in. It frames my whole face! When I have time I use my Benefit Ka-Brow (reviewed here) but if I'm in a rush I just fill them in quickly with a pencil. I love Anastasia's Brow Wiz (reviewed here) with the little spoolie on one end. It stays all day and the caramel color is perfect for me.
Sometimes I'll apply a bit of Touche Eclat or Wonder Pencil along my browbone and on the inner corners of my eyes, but that's optional.
Finally, I need some kind of color on my lips and usually it's Clinique Almost Lipstick in Black Honey or Bite Beauty Agave Lip Mask in Smashed. Something I can put on without a mirror!