So! I got my Miz Mooz order (magically overnight via Endless) last week. I ordered:
The Hype was so awesomely green right out of the box that it was hard to even focus on the Heather, but I gave them both a fair try-on. My favorite thing about the Heather was the strap that ran behind the heel, but I also found that the strap behind my ankle sat very low and it felt like my (narrow) heels would slip out.
The ice color is a really lovely neutral but when you have it sitting next to the most awesome green ever? Eh.
So, the Hype. The color is exactly what I was looking for and they were comfortable immediately. I actually ended up wearing them to a work event that night instead of the shoes I'd worn to work! And I'm wearing them again today:
Please excuse my sad unpolished toes, but hey, green sandals! Everyone needs some.
top: Target (similar)
cardigan: Ann Taylor
pants: Banana Republic (similar)
sandals: Miz Mooz Hype
necklace: Ann Taylor (similar)